Постановление Третьего кассационного суда от 24.06.2024 об административном правонарушении от Роспотребнадзора, оставлено без удовлетворения

TPETIIfr KACCAITI{OHHbIfr CYA
OE IIIE fr IO PTICAI,IKIII,ilI

MEOY

tt

\/./

yn. Ca4onar, A.26,

Camr-flerep6yp.,

Ilb

Cpegnnn rtrKoJra .llb43
163012, o6l. ApxanfeJrbcKtlt, r.
ApxanremcK, yJI. Kuporcrar, A.12

I 901 95

Ten.: (812) 407-92-92
E-mail: 3kas@sudrf.ru
25.06.2024
HaNs

IO "Iopog Apxanrenrcrc"
tt

Ynpanlennro Pocnorpedua4ropa no
Apxanremcxoft o6;racur - 3aMecrrrreJlro
pyKoBoAlrren Mnponoscrofi A.B.
163071, o6l. ApxanrelncKat, r.
ApxaurelrcK, yJI. I aitlapa, 1,. 24

16-334712024

OT

Hanparaaeu HaAJrexarqnra o6parorrr 3aBepemJ[o
Tpeuero
Kaccaqlrourroro
24 lrrorur 2024 'roAa tro AeJry 05 @
Ns 5-629/2023.

cyw

flpunoxenue: Korrat
ropncrurqrln or 24 uKrrs 2024 rotana2

*

cyru

rorrf,ro fflcranoBtreErf, cylFn

o6qef,

rcPacrrotrr

cyqbr Tpenem Eca{xoflHoro cym ofuef,
n I ere- s rrrfirrr ary*.

Ha.ramHrar orAena o6ecneqenat cyAonpou3BoAcrBa
IIO AAI\{IIHIICTPATI{BIIbIM ACNAM

8(812) 407-92-92 (4o6. +;

or

trPffiomflfro€nlrn

H.I,I. Marrosa

TPE TITIZ KA

C

CAII?I OHI{bIfr CYA

OS Tq EIT

rc PI4CMKIIIru{

IIOCTAIIOBJIEHI4E
J\b 16-3347t2024

o\

o

Canrr-llerep6ypr

24 vtonn 2024 roAa

3auecrzrenr [peAceAarent Tpeuero Kaccarlr,roHnoro cy11a o6utefi
rcpvc.{rlKqIaz fopoAKoB A.8., paccMorpee xano6y 3aMecrLrrenfl pyKoBoAr{TeJUr
Ynpae.nenus Pocnorpe6na4:opa ro Apxanrelrcrofi o6lacru Mupouoncxofr A.B.
Ha BCTyIIIABIIII4e B 3aKOHIIyIO CI4ny IIOCTaHOBJTeHUe MEpOBO|O CyAbr{ cyAe6noro
) IacrKa Ns3 Corou6anrcrcoro cy4e6Horo paftowa r. ApxaHrerrbcKa or 2I nox6pr
2023 roAa r4 pelrreuae cy$bLr Conona6anrcKoro pafionnoro cyAa r. ApxaH."ou"*u
or 12 flHBapfl 2024 roAa B orHorrreHr{r4 rvryr{r4qarzurrHoro 6roAxernoro
o6qeo6pa3oBareJrbHoro f{pe)KAeur{rr ropoAcKoro oKpyra < rro AeJry o6 a.rl]ffi{r{c'rparrrBuou trpaBogap\rrreHLrH,
rrpeAycMorpeHHoM .r,1 cr.19.5 KoAII p@,

YCTAHOBilI:
rrocraHoBJreHlreM MapoBofo cyAbE cyAe6noro ) racrKa Ns3
Colorvr6a-ubcKoro cyge6noro paito:aa r. ApxanreJrbcKa or 2l uon6px 2023 roAa,
ocraBJIeHHErM 6e: lrgN{eHeHX{ peruenaeM ay$bu CononnbarrrcKoro pafionnoro cyAa
r. ApxanrenbcKa or 12 fl:rtBapfl 2024 roAa, [por.r3BoAcrBo rro AeJry o6
aAMlIHLIcrparuBHoM rlpaBoHap)rrrreHur{, rrpeAycMorpeHHoM.r.1 cr.I9.5 KoAII P@,
B orHomeHpIIuI N/rFil{qunaJlbHoro 6ro4xernoro o6rqeo6pa3oBareJrbHoro
yrpex{AeHl{rl ropoAcKoro ollpyra < <
6srno [peKparrleHo Ha ocrroBaHr4rr n.2 q.l cr.24.5 KoAII P@ B cBfl3kr c
orcyrcrBu eM c o cr aBa a[MprHI4 crparLIBH o ro rlp aBo Hapyrrre HrIr.

B cooteercrBtllr c [poroKonoM o6 a4rrnnrncrparrrBHoM

[paBonapyrrreHurr

MyHIIIII{narrbHoMy 6rc4xernonay o6rqeo6pa3oBareJrbHoMy f{pexAeHr{ro
ropoAcKoro oKpyfa < < BMeHrrJrocb
sa 4 cenrx6px 2023 roAa HeBbIrIoJIHeHr4e B ycrauoereHHrrfi cpoK 3aKoggoro
IlpeArlI4cauux (npeAynpexAenux) opraHa, ocyqecrBnrarrlero rocyAapcrnensrrfi
HaA3Op (xourponr), o6 ycrpaHeH vru ]Hapyrrgglufr. 3aKoHoAarenbcrBa.

B xano6e, rIoAaHHofi s Tperufi Kaccaqnosnrrfi cy4 o6rqeft rcpucgr4Krrnvr,
3aMecrLITenb pyKoBoALrreJUI Vnpannenas Pocnorpe6ua4sopa no Apxaurelrcnofi
o6nacru Mupouorcr>, yBeAoMnennrrft B coorBercrrlu?r c
rpe6oeanulrMn q..2 ct.30.15 KoAfI P@ o noAarre yra-:annofi xano6rr, B
ycrauoBJrennrrfi cpoK

cBor.D( Bo3pa)Keusfi rte

[peAcraBzJr.

klsyme AoBoAbr xano6nr, np[no]KeHHbre r nefi AorqrMeHTbr
perneHr4r, ocHoBaHuit gnx' ee yAoBJrerBopeHr[rr He ycMarprlrBaro.

z

cy4e6nrre

flo.noxen krfl.vrn cr.30. 1 7 KoAII P@ onpe4enen r{cqeprLrBarousaft repeqenb
peruennfi, Koropble Moxer BbrHecrn cyA rrpn paccMorpentru xano6rr, nporecra Ha
BcTyrILIBItrr{e B 3aKoHI{yIo cr,rJry fIocTaHoBJIeHrae rro AeJry o6 agwtut*tcTpaTr{BrroM
lpaBoHapyruetmvl, pelrreurlrr rro p$ynbraraM paccMorpenus. xano6, uporecroB Ha
3TO IIOCTAHOBJICH}IC.
Cornacno \.2 cr.30.17 KoAII P@ rsr\deneHr{e rocraHoBnerr}rf, uo gerry o6
aAMuHEcTpaTI{BHoM IIpaBoHapyIIIeHI{Izt, peIIIeHIu no p$ynbTaTaM paccMoTp err4fl.
xano6rr, ecnl{ qplr gToM yc}Inl{Baercr aAMr{Hr4crparr{BHoe HaKa3aHrre vrJrnt }rHbrM
o6pa:ona yxyAlxaerct rloJlox(eHrre ryrrra, B orHorueHrrlr Koroporo BbrHeceHbl
yKa3aHHbre rIocraHoBJIeHI{e, pe[reHrre, He Ao[ycKaercr. Yxy4menve noJroxeHufl,
yKuBaHHoro JIrIqa teu 6olee HeAorrycrxMo npr4 orMene cocro.flBrrurxcr uo
4erry o6
:

AAMI,IH}ICTPATHBHOM NPABOHAPYHEI{I4II CYAE6rrrrX AKTOB.

YxasanHas rrpaBoBa.rr no3rrrln

r

KoppeclogAnpyer HopMaM cr.46,

.r.1

cr.50, cr.55 Koncruryqnn Pocczficxofi Oe4epaquu Bo
lronox(eHkrxM,.vr

cr. 4llpororona

ocHoBHbx cso6oA (Pnrrl,

4

J\b7

r

KonseHr{m o

flHBapfl 1950

r.),

B3ar4MocBs3E c
3arqr,rre rpaB qeroBeKa r,r

vrs Korophrx cJreAyer, qro

npolt3BoJrbHoe I43MeHeHrIe [paBoBoro pex('lMa AJrr JrVrrIa, B orHorrrenuur Koropofo
BbrHeceHo oKoHqaTeJIbHOe frocTaHoBJreHlre, HeBo3Mo)KHO - ITOBOpOT K XyAIXeMy
Am ocy)KAeHHoro (oupan4auuoro) rpr4 rrepecMorpe Bcrynr4B[rero B 3aKoHHyro
cnJry [ocTaHoB TIeHLIA, KaK rrpaBr4no, HeAonycTtlM.
B curry n.6 'I. I cr.24.5 KoAII P@ ncre.rerrr4e cpoKa AaBHocrr{ rrpr{BJreqeHrrf,
K aAMl{Hl{cTparznnoft i OTBOTOTB€HHOOTH nBIrfleTcg. o6crosreJrbcTBoM,

ucKrrcqal{llllllM uPousao{crBo no Aeiry o6 aAuunrrcrparr.rBnoM [paBoHapyrrreHrrrd.
:

o6croxreJrbcrBa, Lto"rry
ocHoBaHr{eM .qJUr eoe6yx4euqx B
"Brurre
orHorueHula MEOY roportrcKoro oKpyl'a <>, [poLBBoAcrBa rlo AeJIy o6 aAMr{HncrparrrBHoM rrpaBor{apyrrreHr4u,
cornacHo coAepx(aHIan ry4e6nbrx aKToB, nMeJrlr Mecro Ha [ury 4 ceurx6pt
-

zAn

roAa.
Cporc AaBHocrkI [pnBreqeHurr K aAMr4nlrcrparrannofi orBercrBeHHocrr{ 3a
coBepmeHlIe aAMLIHLIcTpaTI4BHoIo IlpaBoHapylueHl{f,, IlperycMoTpeHHoro .r.1
cr.19.5 KoAfI P@ n orHorlreHvrkrropvrAr4rrecKrrx Jrrrq cocraBJrf,er 90 xanenAapnbrx
AHeft.

flpnuanaax Bo BHXMaHIde rloJlolKenufr cr. 30.17 KoAII P@ u yqurbrBafl, qro.
Ha MoMeHT paccMorpeHn{ e lperreM KaccartrrrroHnoM cyAe o6nteft rcp}rcA[rKqnn

xano6bl AonxHocrHoro nulla cpoK AaBHocrtr npr{BneqeHr4s MEOY ropoAcKoro
oKpyra < <, K aAMr4Hlrcrparzenofi
orBercrBeHHocrll, ycranoBJlennrrfi .r.1 cr.4.5 KoAfI P@ Arla 4annofi Kareropvr{
AeJI, LIcTeK, a rIpou3BOAcTBo nO AeJIy B OTHOIII3HLII4 yK€BaHHoro rcpllAaqecKoro
nvrJa 6rrno [pe{palrleno, Bo3Mox(Hocrb eoso6HoeJreHnr [po]r3BoAcrBa rro
AaHHoMy a.4MI4HlIcrparHBHoMy AeJry a [paBoBofi oqeHrra 4eficraufi, HazsanHoro
JInIIa Ha npe.qMer lJaJrur{.vrfl cocraBa kUrn co6rrrras aAMl{H}rcrparl4Br{oro
lpaBoHapyrreEufl, B TOM qr4cre rro AoBoAaM HaCTOXrqefi xano6u, yrpaqeHa.

llp I{ TaKr{x o6cro.sreJlbcrBax rlpaBoBbrx

ocHoBauraft

x{tlJIoObI He I{MeerC-[, cocrotBlrr?recr

xls

yAoBnerBopeHr{t

IIo Aeny [ocraHoBneHae MI4pOBO|O CyEbLr
cy4e6noro fracrKa Jtlb3 Conona6amcxoro cy4e6uoro pafioHa r. ApxanrelbcKa or
2L voz6px 2023 roAa u pelueHlze cypu Conona6a-rrlcKoro pufto""o.o cyAa
r. ApxanrenbcKa or 12 fl:uBapfl 2024 roAa B ornorrreHr{rr rvryr{r{rlr4n€urbHoro
6rcAxersoro o6qeo6pa:oeareJlbHoro frpex(AeHrrrr ropoAcKoro orgyra < < rro AeJry o6 aAhdnrucrparr{BgoM
npaBoHap)rlrreHxx, npeAycMorpeHHoM q.l cr.19.5 KoAfI Pci, oruenernr 6rrrs se

MOryr.

Buecte

c reM, prcxolr,- I43 HerlocpercrBeurroro

aKToB, ocnoeaHufi craBr{Tb

mAepxagrrf, cyAe6mm
rIoA coMHeHEe 3aKoHHocrb v. o6ocsoBa'Hocrb

cAenaHHbD( CyAaMr,r BbrBoAoB TaroKe He ycMaTpuBaeTcfl.

o6crosrerrbcrB, Koropbre B cprrry n.t. 2-4 cr. 30.17 KoArI P@_ rvrornu 6rt
noele.{b r{3MeHeHrre ]s^'w oiuerry o6xanyeNau* cya"6rrirx' peruenafi, HO
ycTaHoBneHo.

Ha ocnoeawr,r rr3Jrox(eHr{oro n pyKoBoAcrByrcb cr.cr. 30.13
P@,

er

30.17

KoAfI

IIOCTAHOBWI:
locraHoBnennb MrIpoBoro cy4bu cy4e6noro ) {acrKa Ns3 Conorvr6a-rncKoro
cy4e6uoro pafiona r. ApxanreJlrcKa or 21 nox6px 2023 roAa r4 perueHlre cyAbr4
CoroNa6anbcKoro pafronnoro cyAa r. ApxanreJrbcKa or 12 -{HBap{ 2024 roAa B
orHoIrIeHVLr }.ay}/.vrrlxrrallbHoro 6roAxerHoro o6rqeo6p€BoBareJrbHoro
frpexAe'lrt
ropoAcKoro oKpyra                      
Наверх
На сайте используются файлы cookie. Продолжая использование сайта, вы соглашаетесь на обработку своих персональных данных. Подробности об обработке ваших данных — в политике конфиденциальности.

Функционал «Мастер заполнения» недоступен с мобильных устройств.
Пожалуйста, воспользуйтесь персональным компьютером для редактирования информации в «Мастере заполнения».